Zinc Investing: An Exercise in Ethics and Risk Management.
The Usual Routine:
Bret does a bunch of his research at four in the morning. I wake up an hour or so later to a gamut of his charts, current events, and him explaining some big picture economics. Mind blown, I now have a job to do! Research the details, do risk analyses on all investment opportunities, and get a grasp on the market in focus. Last week it was investing in Zinc.
Two Sides of the Same Coin:

"Man, Controller of the Universe" (originally named "Man at the Crossroads") painted by Deigo Riveria
I often think of Diego Rivera’s Man at the Crossroads mural. I first saw this painting over ten years ago at the Palacio de Bellas Artes in Mexico City’s historical center. Originally painted for installation at the Rockefeller Center in New York City, this masterpiece depicts the dichotomous and synonymous facets of postmodernization. On one side you have a consumerist society, women playing cards and smoking, and on the other you have communist leader, Lenin, shaking hands with multi-racial workers. In between these two societal ideologies you have a man, with science and technology at his hands but in no way closer to the answer - what side am I on?
Modern civilization continues to grow in complexity.
The Information Age has led to highly advanced biotechnology, nanotechnologies, autonomization, and artificial intelligence. In this fascinating landscape of the new millennium I feel like the man in Diego’s painting, torn between the natural world and our consumeristic culture. I, just like every other human, consume food to nourish my body and desire things to enrich my life experience. I am also a conservation biologist who strongly believes in the preservation of biodiversity for the betterment of humans and other species. Many conservation biologists and environmentalists are very much against mining. Mining operations decimate ecosystems and contaminate groundwater. However, so many of our technological products rely on metals. From the Hubble Telescope down to your smartphone, even the monitoring equipment environmentalists use. We continue to argue two sides of the same coin.
"Bad fortune is what good fortune leans on, good fortune is what bad fortune hides in. Who knows the ultimate end of this process? Is there no norm of right? Yet what is normal soon becomes abnormal, and what is auspicious soon turn ominous. Long indeed have humans been in quandary." - Lao Tzu
The Zinc Market:
Regardless of whether you are for mining or against it, the current state of the Zinc market is a great exercise in opportunity assessment and risk management. In 2016 Zinc prices increased by 75% due to a supply gap. Going into 2018, zinc demand is still expected to increase at a much higher rate than supply growth. This deficit continues to push prices upward, reaching decade highs in August 2017.

Figure from mining.com
Additionally this supply gap is going to be accelerated by tighter environmental regulations in China, one of the world's largest zinc producers. As a result of these regulations, many of the smaller mines in China have been shut down. Widening the supply gap and opening up market shares for other large producing countries, like Switzerland and Canada.
Investing in Zinc:
After learning about this market opportunity, Bret and I began to search for Zinc stocks. We found two that were very intriguing: Callinex Mines Inc. (CLLXF) and Teck (TECK). Both companies are Canadian, one of the top three zinc producing countries in the world.
Teck is a diversified resource company that operates two of the five largest zinc mines in the world, including Red Dog in Alaska (the world's second largest zinc mine). Because of this, Teck is positioned to take over a sizable amount of China's market share. Additionally, according to my "3 Step Evaluation" Teck is undervalued.
P/E x P/BV = 9.504
Debt/Equity Ratio = 0.32
Current Ratio = 2.17
It is not a common scenario to have all these numbers pass my "long-hold" criteria, especially in today's bloated market. The first time, I saw this kind of "perfect" scenario I was analyzing oil stocks. In 2014 BP stock, according to this criteria, was undervalued. Now there were many other reasons why investing in BP was risky (and a moral "Man at the Crossroads" dilemma), but strictly numbers - it was "good" and was worth looking into. Through further research I found that Teck has grown their revenue by 12.6% and their net income by 142% in 2016. Additionally, they provide dividends to their shareholders (15.63 cents/share).
Callinex Mines Inc. is a mineral exploration company focused on discovering the next zinc and copper rich volcanogenic massive sulfide (VMS) deposits. Callinex is a junior in the zinc market, meaning they do not have as much market share as a long-standing company like Teck. The benefit of this is that their stock is cheaper than majors in the market. Teck's stock for example is about $28 compared to Callinex's stock, which is now around 27 cents.
In my opinion investing in a stock like Callinex, as compared to a stock like Teck, is a bit more risky. Callinex does not have as much market share, and they do not have as long as a track record as Teck. Additionally, Callinex's current focus is exploration. This means that they are spending, spending, spending and not earning. This is reflected in their net profits and negative P/E ratio. On the other hand, because Callinex is cheap you can easily buy more stocks increasing your multiplier for a great swing trade option.
Change the Coin, Not your Side:
Like the man in Diego's painting, many of us sit in quandary to whether or not we should dive into the world of investing. We say things like, "That is capitalism and capitalism is corrupt!" or "Its too risky! We are in a bubble!" We may even think, "Well I can't invest in Zinc because then... I would be a hypocrite!" Then anyone with a smartphone would be a hypocrite, just the same!
I encourage everyone to be objective observers, and to remember that there are two sides to every coin. Both sides must exist for the coin to exist. I say "don't choose a side, play the game and change the coin!"
"The highest form of goodness is like water. Water knows how to benefit all things without striving with them. It stays in places loathed by all men. Therefore, it comes near the Tao" - Lao Tzu
Although The Candlestick Collaborative and all it's collaborators have taken care to ensure that the content on this website is true and accurate, we cannot be held responsible for any inaccuracies in the information herein. The information and content (collectively ‘information’) provided herein are provided by us as general information. Candlestick Collaborative does not guarantee the suitability or potential value of any information or particular investment source. Any information herein is not intended nor does it constitute financial, tax, legal, investment, or other advice. Before making any decision or taking any action regarding your finances, you should consult a qualified Financial Adviser. In the absence of a full needs analysis in respect of a particular investor, the investor understands that there may be limitations on the appropriateness of any information in this website with regard to the investor’s unique objectives, financial situation and particular needs.The use of this website and the online services is entirely at your own risk. You assume full responsibility for the risk or loss resulting from your use of this site and your reliance on the material and information contained on it.





Comments